The Modulation of Historical Narratives Across Geopolitical and Ideological Contexts

Historical narratives, far from being static records of past events, are profoundly shaped by the geographical, political, and ideological contexts in which they are produced. The resultant variation manifests in differences in source material, interpretive biases, selective emphasis, and the justification of power structures or resistance movements. Analyzing diverse primary and secondary source materials spanning ancient Near Eastern polities, medieval Islamic states, and modern colonial conflicts reveals how historians or chroniclers adapt their accounts to specific contemporary imperatives. This scholarly analysis examines how narratives diverge across contexts, particularly focusing on justification of authority in West Africa, interpretation of chronology in antiquity, external representation of Arabia, and contrasting perspectives in the conquests of Al-Andalus and colonial Algeria.

HISTORYTRAVEL

Abdur Sami

9/29/20259 min read

photo of white staircase
photo of white staircase

Narratives of Reform and Conflict in West Africa

In regions undergoing internal political and religious reform, historical narratives frequently serve to legitimize the ideological basis for conflict and reorder social groups. The reformist movement led by Sheikh Uthman dan Fodio in West Africa, for example, articulated its cause by sharply distinguishing between allies and adversaries, often drawing rigid ideological lines.

The Fulani population was divided ethnically and socially into settled groups known as "Fulani Jida" (the mixed or hybridized, due to intermarriage with Hausa tribes), who had adopted Islam in Hausa lands, and nomadic groups known as "Bororoji" (cow herders). The reformist narrative addressed internal dissent by explicitly refuting opposition through formal communication. Muhammad Bello, writing on behalf of Sheikh Uthman dan Fodio, addressed Sheikh Amin al-Kānimī to counter his accusations, explicitly condemning al-Kānimī and allied scholars and jurists as hypocrites (al-munāfiqūn) for aligning with Hausa monarchs against the Muslim community.

Furthermore, the theoretical framework for armed struggle (jihad) was documented explicitly to provide guidelines for the community in Sudan. Sheikh Uthman ibn Fūdi detailed the methodology of war in a manifesto titled "The Document of the People of Sudan," which outlined obedience to the Commander of the Faithful and his deputies, specified the criteria for mandatory emigration (hijra), defined the distinction between the Abode of Islam (Dār al-Islām) and the Abode of War (Dār al-Ḥarb), and identified those whom Muslims must fight. Thus, the historical narrative here is didactic and justificatory, rooted in a precise ideological and political mission.

Chronological and Cultural Disparity in Antiquity

In the study of the Ancient Near East (ANE), historical narratives are often constrained by the nature of the surviving material (archaeological findings and inscriptions), leading to interpretive variations concerning chronology, causality, and regional identity.

The geography of the Levant/Syria, marked by distinct variations in topography—mountains, coasts, and plains—contributed to differing characteristics and tendencies among its inhabitants, influencing regional development and hindering full political unity until relatively late eras, such as the Akkadian period in Iraq. Even within a single geographic area like Mesopotamia, the timeline of cultural advancement resulted in variable historical recognition; South Mesopotamia (Sumer), for instance, was able to enter the historical era sooner than the North due to its earlier development of writing.

Moreover, the process of documenting history, even in the ANE, was complex and iterative. Ancient Egyptian funerary texts, such as the Pyramid Texts, comprised material gathered over long periods and represented the synthesis of varying intellectual capacities and religious doctrines that had previously been dispersed among priests, oral storytellers, and written on papyri or stone until the time of Unis. Different sources also present varied perspectives on causality; for example, while some theories regarding internal Arabian strife (such as the turning of fertile land to desert) emphasize historical climate change, others attribute this degradation to the weakening of political authority. This highlights how the narrative choice—environmental or political—shifts the explanation for fundamental societal transformation.

External and Internal Perspectives in Classical Arabia

The historical record concerning pre-Islamic Arabia demonstrates a significant narrative divide between indigenous Arabian accounts (often based on inscriptions) and external perspectives articulated by Classical Greek and Roman writers.

Classical historians frequently approached Arabia through the lens of external conflicts or trade relations. The earliest reference to the Arabs in a defined manner by Classical writers, such as Herodotus, occurs in the mid-fifth century B.C., particularly concerning the wars between Persia and Egypt under Cambyses. These external narratives were often secondary, derived from hearsay and generalizations, occasionally bordering on the fantastical. Writers like Herodotus gained their information through oral reports, which meant accounts of Arabia were often scattered, dependent on the context of other topics, and sometimes suffered from factual exaggeration.

Roman and Greek geographical texts, such as Strabo's Geographica (written around the transition from B.C. to A.D.), offered detailed descriptions of Arabian cities, tribes, and trading conditions, sometimes drawing directly from military campaigns, such as that of Aelius Gallus. Roman authorities often categorized the region geographically, using terms like Arabia Petraea to denote the rocky region encompassing Sinai and the Nabataean center of Petra.

In contrast, indigenous Arabian sources provide a perspective rooted in local political entities and cultural identity. The identification of peoples like the Sabaeans is clearly established in the Torah and Assyrian texts as politically and economically organized communities, unlike the Minaeans, who were not clearly identified in the same records during the same period. This indigenous record includes efforts to trace ancestry and identity, such as the debate regarding the origin of the term "Arab," which appears in the Torah to mean Bedouins or desert dwellers. In late pre-Islamic Meccan narratives, the city's importance is framed through its role as the center of religious life and the Kaaba, fostering the observance of sacred months, solidifying its place among the Arabs.

Narratives of Conquest and Displacement in Al-Andalus and Sicily

Historical narratives surrounding conquest, particularly the Muslim expansion into the Iberian Peninsula (Al-Andalus) and Sicily, showcase how narratives prioritize justification, condemnation, or cultural legacy depending on the author's allegiance and time.

In the case of the Muslim conquest of Iberia, the narrative is often interwoven with political and personal drama. The widely cited tradition holds that Count Julian encouraged Musa ibn Nusayr to invade Spain due to the rape of his daughter, Florinda, by the Visigothic King Roderic. While subsequent historians view this accusation as a potential fabrication used to justify Roderic’s removal, the persistence of such narratives highlights the need to imbue conquest with moral, often personal, causality.

During the Taifa period in Al-Andalus, political narratives became instruments of critique and self-justification. Al-Mu'tamid ibn Abbad, the ruler of Seville, responded to the increasing military pressure from Alfonso VI of Castile, justifying his decision to call upon the Almoravids despite opposition from his son and advisors. He viewed the potential downfall of the Islamic kingdoms as inevitable due to Qastalī (Castilian) ambition after the fall of Toledo. Later, the Almoravid leader Yūsuf ibn Tashfīn's harsh treatment of Al-Mu'tamid led to a critical historical perspective, viewing Yūsuf's actions as cruel and driven by severe personal condemnation, despite the political excuses offered for neutralizing the Andalusian princes.

In Sicily, narratives of life under Norman rule reveal a different facet of historical transition, focusing on cultural and legal integration. Despite the conquest, documentary evidence indicates that Muslims in Norman Sicily were allowed freedom to dispose of their assets and property, suggesting a legal environment more nuanced than simple displacement narratives often imply. However, the continued presence of diverse elements—Arabs, Berbers, Greeks, Normans—meant that the Islamic culture of Sicily never fully achieved a unified, lasting local spirit, always being supplemented by "immigrant poetry" from Ifriqiya and elsewhere.

Colonial and Nationalistic Narratives in Algeria

In modern contexts, especially colonial and post-colonial periods, historical narratives become intensely polarized, reflecting fundamental conflicts over sovereignty and identity.

In colonial Algeria, French military actions often defined the historical narrative, particularly concerning resistance. For example, the French invasion in 1830 led General Rovigo to seize the most beautiful mosque in Algiers, which was subsequently converted into a cathedral, following an incident where French soldiers stormed the mosque during prayer, killing thousands. Official reports and early histories frequently focused on neutralizing Algerian political claims; French policy documents explicitly state that the goal of supporting traditional Islamic education centers (Zawāyā) was not cultural development, but rather to create "agents and spies" (`umala' wa jawasis*) to enforce intellectual and political surveillance against revolutionary activity.

Early histories written by Algerian scholars under occupation, such as Hamdan Khodja’s The Mirror (1833), offered relatively brief explanations for the causes of the French campaign, indicating a constrained narrative environment dependent largely on Western or pro-colonial sources.

The later nationalist movement responded by crafting a unified national identity rooted in resistance and cultural defense. Nationalist groups in the 1930s defined their collective existence through concise ideological affirmations: "Islam is our religion, Algeria is our homeland, Arabic is our language". This articulation provided a clear historical counterpoint to the French policies that sought to assimilate or eradicate indigenous cultural frameworks. This tension underscores how political struggles force historical narratives to solidify national identity and reject external definitions.

Conclusion

Historical narratives vary significantly across geographic and political contexts, reflecting the agendas, available sources, and cultural priorities of their creators. From the detailed ideological justifications of the West African reformers to the pragmatic legal recognition of Muslims in Norman Sicily, and the contentious struggle for narrative control in colonial Algeria, the resultant historical records are always partial and contextual. Whether dealing with the ambiguities of ANE chronology or the external interpretations of Classical writers regarding Arabia, historians must critically assess how the context of creation—be it religious, political, or geographical—inevitably mediates the representation of the past.

References

  • Bivar, A. D. H. (1961). The wathigat ahl al-sudan amanifests of the fulani jihad. Journal of African History, 11(2), 233–236.

  • Burns, A. (1949). History of Nigeria (4th ed.). George Allen & Unwin.

  • Fage, J. D. (1969). An introduction to the history of West Africa (4th ed.). Cambridge University Press.

  • Hitti, P. K. (1960). History of the Arabs (7th ed.). MacMillan & Co.

  • Huart, C. (1903). La Litterature Arabe. Librairie Orientaliste Paul Geuthner.

  • Musil, A. (1928). Northern Nejd (The Oriental Expleraien And Studies, Vol. 5). American Geographical Society.

  • Nettement, A. (1856). Histoire de la conquete d'Alger. Vaton Freres.

  • Nicholson, R. A. (1962). A literary history of the Arabs (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press.

  • O'Leary, D. D. (1927). Arabia before Muhammad. Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co.

  • Roux, G. (1966). Ancient Iraq (3rd ed.). Penguin Books.

  • Schlumberger, G. (1890). Un Empereur Byzantin au dixième siècle: Nicephore Phocas. Firmin-Didot et cie.

  • Smith, M. G. (1965). The jihad in West Africa: Islam and the modern world. Frank Cass.

  • Strabo. (1917–1949). The geography of Strabo (H. L. Jones, Trans.; Vols. 1–8). William Heinemann/G. P. Putnam’s Sons.

  • Taha, A. W. (1982). Al-Fath wa al-istiqrār al-ʻarabī al-Islāmī fī Shamāl Ifriqiyya wa al-Andalus [The Arab-Islamic Conquest and Settlement in North Africa and Al-Andalus]. Milan, Italy.

  • Tafsir al-Ṭabarī [Exegesis of Al-Ṭabarī]. (n.d.). Dār al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah.

  • Vasiliev, A. A. (1952). History of the Byzantine Empire (Vol. 1). University of Wisconsin Press.

  • al-ʻAnānī, M. A. (1969). Dawlat al-Islām fī al-Andalus [The State of Islam in Al-Andalus] (Vols. 1–4). Maktabat al-Khānjī.

  • al-ʻAnānī, M. A. (1969). Nihāyat al-Andalus [The End of Al-Andalus]. Maktabat al-Khānjī.

  • al-Maqqarī, A. M. (1968). Nafḥ al-ṭayyib min ghuṣn al-Andalus al-raṭīb [The pleasant scent from the moist branch of Al-Andalus] (I. Abbas, Ed.; Vol. 4). Dār Ṣādir.

  • al-Musʻūdī, A. H. (1968). Al-tanbīh wa al-ishrāf [The notification and the supervision]. Dār al-Ṣādir.

  • al-Nuwayrī, M. A. (n.d.). Nihāyat al-arab fī funūn al-adab [The ultimate goal in the arts of literature].

  • al-Ṭabarī, M. J. (1967). Tārīkh al-rusul wa al-mulūk [History of the Prophets and Kings]. Dar Al-Ma'arif.

  • al-Yaqut al-Ḥamawī, S. A. (n.d.). Muʻjam al-buldān [Dictionary of Countries].

  • Ibn al-Athīr, A. (n.d.). Al-Kāmil fi al-Tārīkh [The Complete History].

  • Ibn Khaldūn, W. A. (n.d.). Kitāb al-ʻibar [Book of Lessons].

  • Ibn Quṭiyya, M. ʻU. (1957). Tārīkh iftitāḥ al-Andalus [History of the Conquest of Al-Andalus]. Dar Sader.

  • Ibn ʻIdhārī al-Marrākushī, A. M. (1948). Al-Bayān al-mughrib fī akhbār al-Andalus wa al-Maghrib [The marvelous clarity in the history of Al-Andalus and the Maghrib] (S. Kolan & A. Levy, Eds.; Vol. 1–3). Brill.

  • Muḥammad ibn Bello. (n.d.). Infaq al-Maysūr fī Tārīkh Bilād al-Takrūr [The expenditure of prosperity in the history of the land of Takrur].

  • al-Dūrī, A. A. (n.d.). Al-ʻaṣr al-ʻabbāsī al-awwal [The first Abbasid era].

  • al-Dūrī, A. A. & al-Muṭṭalibī, A. J. (n.d.). Akhbār al-dawlah al-ʻabbāsiyyah [News of the Abbasid State] (Introduction).

  • al-ʻAlī, S. A. (n.d.). Al-Ḥijāz fī ṣadr al-Islām [The Hijaz in early Islam].

  • al-Sālim, M. ʻA. (1962). Ḥaḍārat Miṣr al-qadīmah wa āthāruhā [Ancient Egyptian Civilization and its Monuments] (Vol. 1).

  • al-Sālim, M. ʻA. (1972). The GNBTYW of Thutmosis III's Annals and the South Arabian Gebbanitae of the Classical Writers. Bulletin de l'Institut Français d'Archéologie Orientale, LXXII, 245–262.

  • al-Zubayrī, A. (1970). Lamḥah tārīkhiyyah ʻan al-dawlah al-Jazā’iriyyah [Historical Overview of the Algerian State] (Translation and investigation).

  • Dūzī, R. (1846–1863). Historia Abbadidarum [History of the Abbadids] (Vols. 1–3).

  • Hitti, P. K. (1961). History of the Arabs (7th ed.). MacMillan & Co.

  • Huzayyin, S. A. (1935). Changement Historique du Climat et du Paysage de l'Arabie du Sud. Bulletin of the Faculty of Arts, University of Egypt, III(1).

  • Khodja, H. (1833). Le miroir [The Mirror]. Librairie Orientale de D. Prisse.

  • Kienitz, F. R. (1953). Die Politische Geschichte Aegyptens vom 7 bis Zum 4 Jahr hundert vor der Zeitwende. Springer.

  • Lafuente, M. (1881). Historia General de Espana (Vol. 2). Montaner y Simon.

  • Lammens, H. (1928). L'Arabie Occidentale avant l'Hégire. Imprimerie Catholique.

  • Lewis, B. (1966). The Arabs in history (4th ed.). Harper & Row.

  • Maḥmūd, K. (1987). Tārīkh al-fatāsīn fī akhbār al-buldān wa al-juyūsh wa akābir al-nās [History of the fatasins in the news of countries, armies, and great people]. Ministry of Endowments.

  • Musil, A. (1927). Arabia Deserta. American Geographical Society.

  • Ostrogorsky, G. (1956). History of the Byzantine State (J. Hussey, Trans.). Basil Blackwell.

  • Rostovizeff, M. (1941). Social and Economic History of the Hellenistic World (Vol. 2). Oxford University Press.

  • Scott, S. R. (1904). A History of the Morish Empire in Europe (Vol. 2). J. B. Lippincott Co.

  • Smith, M. G. (1965). The jihad. University of California Press.

  • Watt, W. M. (1967). A History of Islamic Spain (Islamic Surveys 4). Edinburgh University Press.